[Introductory Note – On 7 January 1960, Prince Ferdinando Pio of Bourbon-Two Sicilies, Duke of Calabria, Head of the Royal House of the Two Sicilies and Grand Master of the Constantinian Order, died in Lindau, Bavaria at age 90. He was succeeded by his nephew, Alfonso, Infante of Spain, Prince of Bourbon-Two Sicilies, who became Duke of Calabria, Head of the Royal House of the Two Sicilies and Grand Master of the Constantinian Order. Infante Alfonso’s grandson, Prince Pedro of Bourbon-Two Sicilies, Duke of Calabria, is the current Head of the Royal House of the Two Sicilies and Grand Master of the Constantinian Order. Following Prince Ferdinando Pio’s death in 1960, however, a junior branch of the Two Sicilies dynasty contested Infante Alfonso’s succession and claimed for itself the dignities of Head of the Royal House of the Two Sicilies and Grand Master of the Constantinian Order. This junior branch is sometimes called the Castro branch, because the senior prince of this junior branch uses the title of Duke of Castro. The following article addresses the legal principles governing succession to the Constantinian grand mastership.]
This website, in its Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) section, addressed in detail the following questions:
How is the Grand Master of the Constantinian Order Chosen?, and
What is the Connection between the Constantinian Order and the Royal House of Bourbon of the Two Sicilies?, and
Why does another Prince of the Two Sicilies currently dispute the rights of the Grand Master?
See: https://constantinianorder.us/faqs/
The responses to these queries stated in essence that:
- succession to the Constantinian Grand Mastership is governed by canon law and passes to the senior male primogeniture descendant of King Ferdinand I of the Two Sicilies (formerly King Ferdinand IV of Naples and III of Sicily), as designated primogeniture heir of the House of Farnese. Today, the senior descendant of King Ferdinand I by male primogeniture is the current Grand Master, HRH Prince Pedro of Bourbon-Two Sicilies, Duke of Calabria, Count of Caserta, Head of the Royal House of the Two Sicilies.
- the position of Grand Master of the Constantinian Order, governed by canon law, is a completely separate dignity from the position of Head of the Royal House of Bourbon of the Two Sicilies, which is governed by the Pragmatic Decree of King Charles III of Spain dated 6 October 1759, by the last Royal Constitution of the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies, and by Two Sicilies civil law. Although both dignities have been held for centuries by the same person, they could be inherited by different heirs, because each is governed by its own succession rules. The Constantinian Order is thus not a dynastic order of the House of the Two Sicilies but is instead an inheritance as heirs of the House of Farnese, whilst, for example, the Order of Saint Januarius (San Gennaro) is a dynastic order of the Two Sicilies dynasty.
- The claim of a junior Prince of the Two Sicilies to the Constantinian grand mastership has no basis in law, because the junior prince in question is not the male primogeniture heir of King Ferdinand I. Instead, he is only 6th in the line of succession. (This gentleman’s claim to be the head of the Two Sicilies dynasty is similarly mistaken, for the reasons set forth on this website in the response to the FAQ “Why does another Prince of the Two Sicilies currently dispute the rights of the Grand Master?” But the topic of the position of dynastic head is beyond the scope of this article.)
The website’s FAQ section has prompted a number of e-mails requesting more details on these questions. In response to this request, we are providing below the texts of some key historical documents.
As background, in 1698, the Grand Mastership of the Constantinian Order was acquired by Francesco Farnese, Duke of Parma. Pope Innocent XII’s apostolic brief Sincerae Fidei in 1699 and Holy Roman Emperor Leopold I’s imperial decree Agnoscimus et notum facimus of the same year confirmed to Francesco Farnese and his heirs the position of Grand Master, as a dignity separate and apart from the House of Farnese’s sovereignty over the Duchy of Parma.
In 1705, the Farnese grand master granted the Order new statutes, which were approved the following year (1706) by Pope Clement XI, which established the Grand Mastership as an ecclesiastical office passing by primogeniture among the male heirs of the Farnese family, a requirement confirmed again in the 1718 papal bull Militantis Ecclesiae. Below are the 1706 and 1718 papal documents.
I. Brief of Pope Clement XI — 24 October 1706
(Approval of the Order’s statutes and confirmation of the succession to the Grand Mastership by male primogeniture within the House of Farnese)
| Latin (key clauses) | English Translation |
| “…Nos motu proprio ac certa scientia, auctoritate apostolica tenore praesentium, approbamus, confirmamus, et perpetuo valere volumus Statuta Ordinis Militaris S. Georgii sub titulo Constantini Magni, per Illustrissimum ac Excellentissimum Principem Franciscum Farnesium, Parmensem ac Placentinum Ducem, recognita et reformata…” | “…We, by our own act and certain knowledge, by apostolic authority and by these presents, approve, confirm, and will that there shall perpetually remain in force the Statutes of the Military Order of Saint George under the title of Constantine the Great, reviewed and reformed by the Most Illustrious and Excellent Prince Francesco Farnese, Duke of Parma and Piacenza…” |
| “…et declaramus dictam Magisterii dignitatem hereditaria esse in domo Farnesia, et ad legitimum primogenitum masculum ex dicta familia, eiusque posteros masculos in infinitum descendere debere…” | “…and we declare that the dignity of the Grand Mastership is hereditary in the House of Farnese, and that it must descend to the legitimate male primogeniture heir of that family and to their male descendants forever…” |
II. Papal Bull Militantis Ecclesiae — Pope Clement XI, 27 May 1718
(Final and definitive settlement of the Order’s status and further confirmation of succession to the Grand Mastership by male primogeniture within the House of Farnese)
| Latin (key clauses) | English Translation |
| “Militantis Ecclesiae triumphos, quos Deo duce sub vexillo sancti Georgii, Constantinianus Ordo, a Constantino Magno coeptus, per tot saecula retulit, laudabiliter continuare desiderantes, Nos… eundem Ordinem, sub regulis et statutis a nobis approbatis, perpetuo confirmamus et stabilimus.” | “Desiring that the triumphs of the Church Militant, which under God’s guidance the Constantinian Order—begun by Constantine the Great under the banner of Saint George—has for so many centuries nobly continued, may likewise be perpetuated, We… approve, confirm, and establish for all time that same Order under the rules and statutes approved by Us.” |
| “…ac Magisterium illius in domo Farnesia stabilimus, et perpetuo manere decernimus, descendendumque per lineam masculinam legitime natorum, juxta tenorem statutorum ab eodem duce editum…” | “…and We establish the Grand Mastership thereof in the House of Farnese, decreeing that it shall remain there forever, to descend through the male line of lawful birth, according to the tenor of the statutes issued by that same Duke.” |
| “…nulli hominum liceat praesentes litteras infringere vel illis contraire; si quis autem hoc attentare praesumpserit, indignationem omnipotentis Dei ac beatorum Apostolorum Petri et Pauli se noverit incursurum.” | “…Let no man dare to infringe or oppose these letters; and if anyone should presume to attempt it, let him know that he will incur the wrath of Almighty God and of the blessed Apostles Peter and Paul.” |
NOTE: In 1731, the House of Farnese died out in the male line. The positions both of Grand Master of the Constantinian Order and Duke of Parma then passed, as separate dignities, to Prince Charles of Bourbon, Infante of Spain, who was deemed the heir of the House of Farnese, as the eldest son of Elisabeth Farnese and King Philip V of Spain. Charles was forced to surrender the Duchy of Parma in 1736, but he retained the separate position of Grand Master of the Constantinian Order and continued to administer the Constantinian Order’s Parma estates and membership, despite no longer being Parma’s sovereign duke.
Charles’s succession as Grand Master of the Constantinian Order occurred in 1731. He subsequently became King of Naples and Sicily in 1734.
In 1759, the same Charles, still King of Naples and Sicily, inherited the throne of Spain in succession to his childless elder half-brother. He then became King Charles III of Spain, and his eldest son became the next in line to the Spanish throne. Two months after succeeding to the Spanish throne, King Charles III of Spain abdicated the thrones of Naples and Sicily to his second surviving son, Ferdinand, in order to comply with two international treaties which required that the monarch of Spain not hold any sovereignties in Italy. (Ferdinand thus became King Ferdinand IV of Naples and King Ferdinand III of Sicily. In 1816, after the kingdoms of Naples and Sicily were united, he became King Ferdinand I of the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies.) Some ten days after abdicating the thrones of Naples and Sicily in 1759, Charles III of Spain assigned and delegated to his son Ferdinand the position of primogeniture Farnese heir and, as such, the dignity of Constantinian Grand Master. Thus, Charles III initially remained Constantinian Grand Master for a period of time after ascending the Spanish throne and after abdicating the thrones of Naples and Sicily. [King Charles III of Spain also retained for several years the Grand Mastership of the Illustrious Royal Order of Saint Januarius (San Gennaro) which he had founded as King of Naples in 1738. Thus, from 1759 to 1766, the Order of Saint Januarius was the second Order of the Kingdom of Spain, immediately after the Golden Fleece. On 9 December 1766, however, King Charles III abdicated the Grand Mastership of the Order of Saint Januarius to his son, King Ferdinand of Naples, and it resumed its status as an order of the Two Sicilies dynasty.]
Following the succession of King Ferdinand of Naples and Sicily to the position of Grand Master of the Constantinian Order, the Marquis Bernardo Tanucci, first minister of the Kingdom of Naples, issued two letters.
III. Marchese Bernardo Tanucci’s Letter informing the Grand Prior of the Constantinian Order of the Cession of the title of Grand Master of the Constantinian Order — 16 October 1759
(Archivio di Stato di Napoli, Ministero degli Affari Esteri, b. 4019)
| Italian | English Translation |
| Al tempo stesso di essere S. M. Catt.a devenuta alla solenne cessione di questi Regni delle Sicilie in favore del suo terzogenito il Serenissimo Infante D. Ferdinando, già mio Re e Signore, | At the same time that His Catholic Majesty [King Charles III of Spain] came to the solemn cession of these Kingdoms of the Sicilies in favor of his third (second surviving) son, the Most Serene Infante Don Ferdinando, now my King and Lord, |
| dichiara estendersi tale Cessione al designato Gran Magistero dell’Ordine Costantiniano alla Maestà dell’appresso Don Ferdinando IV, Re delle Due Sicilie, | he declares that this cession extends likewise to the designated Grand Mastership of the Constantinian Order, in favour of His Majesty Don Ferdinando IV, King of the Two Sicilies, |
| come Primogenito legittimo Farnesiano nei Stati, Titoli e Diritti Italiani, benché terzogenito per natura. | as the legitimate Farnese first-born in the Italian States, Titles, and Rights, though third-born by nature. |
| Io, da Real Ordine di S. M. il Re mio Signore e Gran Maestro, significo e partecipo a V. Ill.ma tal Cessione e rispettiva Resignazione, | By Royal Order of His Majesty the King [Ferdinand] my Lord and Grand Master, I notify and communicate to Your Most Illustrious Lordship this cession and corresponding resignation, |
| affinché restandone nella dovuta intelligenza, in qualità di Gran Priore dell’Ordine lo faccia così intendere alla Congregazione de’ Cavalieri Gran Croci, | so that, being duly informed thereof, you in your capacity as Grand Prior of the Order may likewise make it known to the Congregation of Knights Grand Cross, |
| e disponga la medesima Reale Sovrana determinazione, Cessione e Resignazione venga registrata ove convenga, | and arrange that the same Royal and Sovereign determination, cession, and resignation be registered wherever appropriate, |
| norma e regolamento successivo nell’amministrazione dell’Ordine Costantiniano. | as a norm and rule to be observed henceforth in the administration of the Constantinian Order. |
| In mio particolare rinnovo a V. Ill.ma il rispetto, con cui mi reggio di essere di V. Ill.ma e Reverend.ma. | In particular I renew to Your Most Illustrious Lordship the respect with which I remain, Your Most Illustrious and Reverend Servant. |
| Cui a maggior dilucidazione dell’assunto compiego l’atto solenne di Cessione di S. M. Catt.a in favore di questi Regni, ma anche di tutti i Diritti, Titoli ed Azioni Italiane, nel quale va compreso il Magistero dell’Ordine Costantiniano. | To which, for greater clarification of the subject, I append the solemn Act of Cession of His Catholic Majesty in favour of these Realms and likewise of all Italian Rights, Titles, and Claims, among which is included the Grand Mastership of the Constantinian Order. |
IV. Marchese Bernardo Tanucci’s Letter to the Deputation of the Constantinian Order — 11 December 1759
(Giuseppe Castrone, Delle speciali caratteristiche dell’Ordine Costantiniano, Napoli 1877, pp. 22–23 n. 31)
| Italian | English Translation |
| Illustrissimi Signori e Padroni colendissimi, | Most Illustrious and Most Honoured Lords, |
| Fin dal 16 passato ottobre si ebbe qui la necessaria avvertenza di prevenire con dispaccio cotesto Monsignore Gran Priore dell’Ordine Costantiniano, | Already on the past 16 October there was here the necessary occasion to advise, by dispatch, Monsignor the Grand Prior of the Constantinian Order, |
| sulla solenne Cessione e Resignazione che S. M. Cattolica si era servita di fare del Gran Magistero dell’Ordine in favore di questo nuovo Sovrano delle Sicilie Ferdinando IV, | concerning the solemn cession and resignation which His Catholic Majesty [King Carlos III of Spain] had been pleased to make of the Grand Mastership of the Order in favour of the new Sovereign of the Sicilies, Ferdinando IV, |
| come Primogenito legittimo Farnesiano nei Stati, Titoli e Dritti Italiani, benché terzogenito per natura. | as the legitimate Farnese first-born in the Italian States, Titles, and Rights, though third-born by nature. |
| … Alle quali unisco un esemplare dell’atto di Cessione di cui si fa qui menzione. | … To these I enclose a copy of the Act of Cession of which mention is here made. |
NOTE: That King Charles III of Spain executed separate abdications in 1759 (first, the abdication of the thrones of Naples and Sicily, and then later the separate abdication of the Grand Mastership of the Constantinian Order) underlined the fact that the Constantinian Order and its Grand Mastership were separate and independent from the Crowns of Naples and Sicily (later the Crown of the Two Sicilies). Charles’s abdication of the thrones of Naples and Sicily when he became King of Spain was in execution of the Pragmatic Decree of 1759, which specified that the Crown of Naples and the Crown of Spain must not be united and held by the same monarch. The Pragmatic Decree was intended to address questions concerning the balance of power in Europe and was enacted under the provisions of the treaties of Vienna of 1737 and Naples of 1759.
V. The 1763 Papal Monitor issued in 1763 by Pope Clement XIII in respect of the Constantinian Order.
(This confirmed the Order’s status as a religious body of the Church governed by canon law and that King Ferdinand was the legitimate Grand Master to whom all owed obedience on pain of excommunication should they deny his legitimate succession. It also confirmed the Order’s autonomy and that it was not subject to the civil law of any state.)
| Latin Text | English Translation |
| Clemens Papa XIII ad perpetuam rei memoriam. | Pope Clement XIII, for the perpetual remembrance of this matter. |
| Cum Sacrum Militare Constantinianum Ordinem Sancti Georgii a Nobis Praedecessoribus Romanis Pontificibus fuerit agnitum, approbatum ac confirmatum tamquam veram religionem ecclesiasticam sub regula canonice erectam, | Since the Sacred Military Constantinian Order of Saint George has been recognised, approved, and confirmed by Our predecessor Roman Pontiffs as a true religious body of the Church, erected under canon law, |
| atque ejusdem Magisterium in Farnesiana Domu per legitimam primogenituram masculinam perpetuo descendere decretum sit, | and since the Grand Mastership of the same has been decreed to descend perpetually in the House of Farnese by legitimate male primogeniture, |
| Nos graviter intelleximus nonnullos homines praesumptionis spiritu ductos nomen, titulos vel insignia dicti Ordinis usurpare, ac falsos praetextus sibi adstruere quasi quibusdam auctoritatibus confirmatos, | We have learned with deep sorrow that certain men, moved by a spirit of presumption, have dared to usurp the name, titles, or insignia of the said Order and to claim false pretexts as though confirmed by certain authorities, |
| quae res in gravem injuriam dictae Religionis ejusque legitimi Magistri cadere perspiciuntur. | an act which clearly brings grave injury to that religious body and to its lawful Grand Master. |
| Ideo Nos, auctoritate apostolica, praesenti Monitorio monemus et mandamus omnibus Christifidelibus, tam laicis quam ecclesiasticis, ne dicti Ordinis nomen aut insignia sine licentia legitimi Magistri Ferdinandi Regis Neapolis et Siciliae sub poenis excommunicationis latae sententiae usurpent. | Therefore, by apostolic authority, through this present Monitory Letter, We admonish and command all the faithful of Christ, both lay and clerical, that no one may use the name or insignia of the said Order without permission of its lawful Grand Master, Ferdinand, King of Naples and Sicily, under pain of excommunication latae sententiae. |
| Praeterea decernimus et declaramus dictum Ordinem ab aliquarum potestatum temporalium jurisdictione omnino esse immunem, atque in iis solum Sanctae Sedis auctoritati subiectum. | Furthermore, We decree and declare that the said Order is wholly exempt from the jurisdiction of any temporal power and is subject only to the authority of the Holy See in these matters. |
| Nulli ergo omnium hominum liceat praesentes litteras nostri Monitorii infringere vel illis temerario ausu contradire; si quis autem hoc attemptare praesumpserit, indignationem Omnipotentis Dei ac Beatorum Apostolorum Petri et Pauli se noverit incursurum. | Therefore let it be permitted to no one at all to violate these letters of Our Monitor or to oppose them by rash boldness; and if anyone should presume to attempt this, let him know that he will incur the wrath of Almighty God and of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul. |
| Datum Romae apud Sanctam Mariam Majorem, anno Domini MDCCLXIII, die XXIV mensis Septembris, Pontificatus nostri quinto. | Given at Rome, at Saint Mary Major, in the year of Our Lord 1763, on the 24th day of September, the fifth year of Our Pontificate. |
NOTE: For his part, King Ferdinand confirmed the independence of the Constantinian Order from the Crowns of Naples and Sicily in a 1796 decree, which made clear that In his (Ferdinand’s) royal person there exists two very distinct qualities, the one of monarch of the Two Sicilies, and the other of grand master of the illustrious, royal and military Constantinian Order, which though united gloriously in the same person form nonetheless at the same time two separate independent lordships. The text of portions of this decree follows.
VI. 1796 DECREE OF KING FERDINAND IV CONFIRMING THE SEPARATION OF THE GRAND MASTERSHIP OF THE CONSTANTINIAN ORDER FROM THE TWO SICILIES CROWN
| Italian (De Franchis 1837, II: 195-197) | English Translation |
| Ordine Costantiniano di San Giorgio – Decreto di S.M. Ferdinando IV, 27 marzo 1796 | Constantinian Order of Saint George – Decree of His Majesty Ferdinand IV, 27 March 1796 |
| Volendo Noi, per togliere ogni dubbio che potesse nascere in avvenire circa la natura e l’indole dell’Ordine Costantiniano di San Giorgio, dichiarare e stabilire con pubblica autorità i veri principî della sua istituzione, | Wishing, in order to remove every doubt that might arise in future concerning the nature and character of the Constantinian Order of Saint George, to declare and establish with public authority the true principles of its institution, |
| Dichiariamo che l’Ordine Costantiniano è una Religione militare sotto immediata dipendenza della Santa Sede Apostolica, riconosciuta e confermata dai Sommi Pontefici, e che perciò esso non può essere né considerato né governato come semplice istituzione secolare o politica. | We declare that the Constantinian Order is a military religious body under the immediate dependence of the Holy Apostolic See, recognised and confirmed by the Sovereign Pontiffs, and therefore it can in no way be regarded or governed as a mere secular or political institution. |
| Dichiariamo altresì che la dignità del Gran Magistero non è annessa alla Corona del Nostro Regno, ma costituisce una eredità distinta e separata, derivata dai Duchi Farnesi, e trasmessa a Noi per legittima successione mascolina della loro stirpe. | We further declare that the dignity of the Grand Mastership is not annexed to the Crown of Our Realm, but constitutes a distinct and separate inheritance, derived from the Dukes of the House of Farnese and transmitted to Us by legitimate male succession of their line. |
| Ordiniamo pertanto che in tutti gli atti pubblici e privati, civili ed ecclesiastici, sia fatta chiara distinzione tra la Nostra Maestà Reale e la Nostra qualità di Gran Maestro dell’Ordine Costantiniano. | We therefore order that in all public and private acts, both civil and ecclesiastical, a clear distinction shall be made between Our Royal Majesty and Our capacity as Grand Master of the Constantinian Order. |
| E comandiamo ai Nostri Ministri e Segretari di Stato, e a chiunque spetti, che abbiano esatto e inviolabile riguardo alla presente dichiarazione, come legge fondamentale dell’Ordine, da conservarsi perpetuamente. | And We command Our Ministers and Secretaries of State, and all whom it may concern, to hold exact and inviolable regard for the present declaration, as a fundamental law of the Order, to be preserved in perpetuity. |
| Dato in Napoli, addì ventisette marzo millesettecentonovantasei, anno XXXVI del Nostro Regno. | Given at Naples, this twenty-seventh day of March 1796, the thirty-sixth year of Our Reign. |
| Ferdinando IV – (segue la formula di registro e di esecuzione) | Ferdinand IV – (Here follow the formal attestations and registration clauses.) |
King Ferdinand’s 1796 decree, added as an appendix to the Order’s statutes, merely formalises what the Holy See had fully recognised at the time Ferdinand became Constantinian Grand Master in 1759: namely, that succession to the position of Constantinian Grand Master, a dignity based in canon law, was separate from other positions, such as the secular position of King of Naples and Sicily. The Holy See recognized this again in 1861, when the Two Sicilies dynasty lost its crown. Indeed, the Holy See continued to accord privileges and recognition to the Constantinian Order for decades into the 20th century after the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies had ceased to exist.
(It is interesting to note in passing that, in their official portraits as Kings of Naples and later Kings of the Two Sicilies, the monarchs wear the chivalric orders of the Two Sicilies dynasty but do not wear the insignia of the Constantinian Order. In contrast, these same monarchs, in their official portraits as Grand Masters of the Constantinian Order, wear their Constantinian insignia but do not wear the chivalric orders of the Two Sicilies dynasty. This is because the Constantinian Order was never a chivalric order of the Two Sicilies dynasty, and, as stated above, the position of Constantinian grand master was a separate dignity from that of King.)
The Order’s Statutes of 1919, confirmed by the Holy See, and the revised Statutes of 1934-1943 (in the articles governing the succession to the Grand Mastership) state explicitly that the “dignity of Grand Master, reserved to the House of Bourbon, as heirs of the House of Farnese, is transmitted by male primogeniture.”
The Order’s Royal Deputation in 1935 issued a lengthy historical statement in which the separate nature of the Order from the Crown of the Two Sicilies was emphasised.
It is worth repeating that succession to the Constantinian Grand Mastership and succession to the dignity of head of the Bourbon Two Sicilies dynasty are governed by two very different sets of laws. Under canon law, because the dignity of Constantinian Grand Master is an ecclesiastical office with episcopal powers (powers delegated to the Order’s Grand Prior, now Cardinal Gerhard Müller), the Grand Mastership can only be held by males. If the male dynasts of the House of Bourbon- Two Sicilies were to die out, the Grand Mastership would pass to the House of Bourbon-Parma, which is the next senior male line of descent from Elisabeth Farnese, Queen Consort of King Philip V of Spain. In contrast, under the Two Sicilies dynastic laws, in the event the male dynasts of the House of the Two Sicilies were to die out, the succession to the dignity of head of the dynasty would pass to the female dynast most closely related to the last dynastic head.
Since the accession of King Ferdinand to the position of Constantinian Grand Master in 1759, the Constantinian Grand Mastership has passed by strict male primogeniture among his direct descendants in the male line of the House of Bourbon-Two Sicilies.
The present Grand Master, HRH Prince Pedro of Bourbon, Prince of the Two Sicilies, Duke of Calabria succeeded his father as Grand Master in 2015. Prince Pedro is the senior living descendant of King Ferdinand I of the Two Sicilies (formerly King Ferdinand IV of Naples and III of Sicily) by male primogeniture and is thus also the heir of the House of Farnese. The Grand Master’s heir is his eldest son, HRH Prince Jaime, Duke of Noto and Grand Prefect of the Constantinian Order.
VII. THE ACT OF CANNES OF 1900
Prince Charles, Duke of Castro (born 1963), a junior member of the Two Sicilies dynasty, bases his mistaken claim to be head of the Constantinian Order on the so-called Act of Cannes of 1900. This document, however, has absolutely no legal bearing on the Grand Mastership of the Constantinian Order.
The Act of Cannes was signed in 1900 by HRH Prince Carlo of the Two Sicilies, great-grandfather of the current Grand Master, HRH Prince Pedro, shortly before Don Carlo’s marriage to the Princess of Asturias, then the heiress to the throne of Spain. In essence, the Act of Cannes specified that Prince Carlo renounced his eventual rights to the Two Sicilies Crown in the event his wife were to succeed to the Spanish throne and he were to become King Consort of Spain. (The document made no mention whatever of the Constantinian Order which, as explained above, is a dignity separate and independent from the Two Sicilies Crown.)
King Charles III of Spain in his Pragmatic Decree of 1759 had confirmed the right of all his male line descendants to both the Spanish and Two Sicilies thrones, but prohibited the union of the Spanish Crown with that of the Two Sicilies in one person, in order to preserve the European balance of power. The Act of Cannes expressly stated that it was signed “in execution of the Pragmatic Decree [of 1759]”, and “in accord with the laws and customs of our family.” The Pragmatic Decree and the family laws and customs merely prohibited the union of the two crowns. The Act of Cannes was intended to address a possible future event: what would happen if the Princess of Asturias became Queen Regnant of Spain and her husband Don Carlo King Consort of Spain. If this condition were to occur, Don Carlo would have had to renounce his Two Sicilies rights in favour of his second son (as his first son would then automatically be heir to the Spanish Crown). (There were many instances of marriages between princes and princesses of both kingdoms between 1759 and 1960 without any consideration of the possibility that these might prejudice the rights of their descendants. Indeed, in 1900, weeks before Don Carlo’s marriage, the Spanish Minister of Justice had stated in the Spanish parliament, the Cortes, that there was no need for any renunciations by either Prince Don Carlo or his future wife, and if one was made it would in any case by null and void, in part because the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies had ceased to exist in 1861.)
In the event, the Princess of Asturias never became Queen of Spain and her husband never became King Consort. Therefore, the possible event on which the conditional renunciation of Prince Carlo was predicated never came to pass. Thus, the Act of Cannes did not prejudice any of the Two Sicilies rights of Prince Carlo and his descendants. A conditional declaration is of no effect if the condition on which it is based does not occur.
Oddly enough, however, the Act of Cannes is the sole basis on which the Duke of Castro claims to be both head of the Two Sicilies dynasty and head of the Constantinian Order. The fact that the Act of Cannes was a conditional declaration which never took effect means that his claim to be dynastic head is without legal basis. But to pretend that the Act of Cannes, which does not even mention the separate and independent dignity of Grand Master of the Constantinian Order, pertains in any way to the Constantinian Order is wholly without merit.
The legality of the succession in 1964 of Prince Pedro’s father, the late Prince and Infante Carlos, Duke of Calabria, to the Headship of the Royal House of the Two Sicilies and to the Constantinian Grand Mastership was in 1983 and 1984 investigated by five of the highest state bodies of the Kingdom of Spain. All five independent state bodies (headed by the Council of State) reported unanimously to the King of Spain that Don Carlos, Duke of Calabria was the legitimate holder of both dignities. These five Spanish state institutions were: the Institute of Heraldry and Genealogy; the Royal Academy of Jurisprudence and Legislation; the Ministry of Foreign Affairs; the Ministry of Justice; and the Council of State.
This legal examination was ordered by King Juan Carlos of Spain when, after the restoration of the Spanish monarchy in 1975, the father of the current Duke of Castro had sought the King’s recognition and had sent numerous documents on the dispute to His Majesty. Because King Charles III of Spain (who had also been King Charles VII of Naples and Sicily) had promulgated the rules of the Two Sicilies succession in his Pragmatic Decree of 1759, which he had signed in execution of several treaty obligations to which Spain remained bound, it was thought that the Spanish Crown, under King Juan Carlos as successor of King Charles III, was the appropriate authority to interpret the provisions of the succession and to resolve the dispute in a definitive manner. The Spanish Crown did exactly that.
THE PORTRAITS ABOVE: The portraits above depict Francis II of Bourbon, last reigning King of the Two Sicilies. Both portraits depict him in his role as King of the Two Sicilies. In these portraits, he wears the breast stars and decorations of the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies. He does not wear the Constantinian Order, because it was not an order of the Crown of the Two Sicilies and because the dignity of Constantinian Grand Master was separate from the dignity of King of the Two Sicilies. One will not see any portraits of Kings of Naples or Kings of the Two Sicilies wearing the Constantinian star alongside the stars of the Naples or Two Sicilies dynastic orders.
