The book “The Grand Master – The Sacred Military Constantinian Order of Saint George and Ferdinand IV of Bourbon between revolution and restoration” by Father Maurizio Modugno, Chaplain of Merit, has just been published (in Italian – Aracne, 2024 – 192 pages). It has a Preface by the current Constantinian Grand Master, HRH Prince Pedro of Bourbon-Two Sicilies, Duke of Calabria, Count of Caserta, Head of the Royal House of Two Sicilies. On the cover, there is the Constantinian Cross, a sculpture from the second half of the 18th century, originally placed on the top of the façade of the Church of Sant’Antonio Abate in Naples and now preserved inside the church.
The book will be launched on Wednesday 22 May 2024, after the celebration of the monthly Holy Mass of the Delegation of Rome and Vatican City of the Sacred Military Constantinian Order of Saint George. The Mass will be at 6.30 pm at the Magistral Basilica of Santa Croce al Flaminio in Rome.
Below we provide a summary of the book, the text of the Preface, the Introduction, the Table of Contents and the text from the back cover.
Summary
“The history of the Sacred Military Constantinian Order of Saint George has its point of greatest institutional definition and maximum honorific splendour in the years of the reign of Ferdinand IV of Bourbon, King of the Two Sicilies [note: originally King Ferdinand IV of Naples and III of Sicily, he became King Ferdinand I when the two kingdoms were merged into the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies]. The central three decades of that reign, from 1799 to 1815, were shaken by the eruption in Italy of a sequence of shock waves which began in Paris, epicenter of the storming of the Bastille and the French Revolution.”
Preface by HRH Prince Pedro of Bourbon-Two Sicilies, Duke of Calabria, Count of Caserta, Head of the Royal House of the Two Sicilies, Grand Master of the Sacred Military Constantinian Order of Saint George
It is with great satisfaction that I write this Preface to the book by our brother and chaplain of merit of the Order, Father Maurizio Modugno, already the author of various essays and historiographical works and above all the author of Il Vitello Rampante, a history of his family in which the Constantinian Order played a fundamental role.
His new book is entitled The Grand Master and focuses directly on the history of the Sacred Military Constantinian Order of Saint George in its point of greatest institutional definition and maximum splendour, that is, the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies during the reign of King Ferdinand IV of Bourbon.
The central fifteen years of that reign, from 1799 to 1815, were shaken by the eruption in Italy of the shock waves that started in Paris, the epicenter of the storming of the Bastille, and continued with the affirmation of the Franco-Italian Republics first and then of the Napoleonic Empire and its satellites.
The research and recovery of historical facts in this unique book bring to the attention of the reader the institutional, ceremonial and social structure of the Kingdom of Naples between the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, drawing a new full-length portrait of Ferdinand IV. The book reveals him in all his courage, in all his resilience to Dante’s “strokes of fortune,” in all his love for the people as well as for his family and his orders of chivalry. The Sacred Military Constantinian Order plays a leading role in this volume, in tracing it back to its origins, in the perception of it in the era discussed, in the clear establishment of succession to its grand mastership by uninterrupted male primogeniture, and in its indomitable vitality even in the years of the Royal Court’s transfer to Palermo. I believe it is essential to remember that being a Constantinian knight today requires attention to the research and knowledge of and a profound connection with our most ancient and illustrious roots. There is an exceptional moral lesson that stretches from Constantine the Great to Angelo Comnenus, from the Farnese to the Bourbons, which always in a very clear way emanates from the events and people to what for everyone has been and must continue to be a golden and renowned devotion to chivalry.
I therefore convey to the author all my appreciation for his effort, expressing my hopes for the complete success of this book, which is also rich in magnificent iconography, which I believe constitutes an important step in disseminating fuller knowledge of the indisputable continuity of the Sacred Military Constantinian Order.
Pedro of Bourbon-Two Sicilies, Duke of Calabria, Grand Master
Introduction
“Although I feel very dark to the blows of fortune”
(Dante, Par. XVII, vv. 19-24)
Of the numerous documents and books published on the history of the Sacred Military Constantinian Order of Saint George, there has until now been no work devoted specifically to the Reign and Grand Mastership of Ferdinand IV of Bourbon and framed between the French Revolution of 1789 and the Restoration of 1815. In the Kingdom of Naples the Jacobin uprising can be dated from 1799, that is, from the arrival in the city of General Championnet and the establishment of the Neapolitan Republic. This is the so-called “French Decade,” a time during which Napoleon Bonaparte had proclaimed the end of the House of Bourbon of Naples and its replacement with “a prince of my House.” This period also witnessed the explicit suppression and subversion of the Orders of Chivalry belonging to the Crown of the ousted Ferdinand and to the creation of new orders and decorations established in order to reward those who had distinguished themselves in the battles for the victory of the new monarchies of Joseph Bonaparte first and then later of Joachim Murat.
As is known, Bonaparte’s hope for the end of the Bourbons would not be realized. Ferdinand IV of Naples resumed the throne on 7 June 1815, as Ferdinand I, King of the Two Sicilies. The Constantinian Order survived, in Dante’s style “tetragon to the blows of fortune,” either because of the uninterrupted activity of the Palermo Deputation of the Order at the Church of the Magione, or because of those in Naples or Puglia or Calabria or the Abruzzi who had maintained – dum tacebant clamantes – their attachment and loyalty to the Order and its Grand Master.
The institutional, historical and chivalric analysis of this Kingdom in such a turbulent era has been conducted here magnum laborem exercens, that is, with the difficulty that always derives from the first examination of documents never studied by anyone and from the need to infer the where and when of situations and people. We have previously dedicated space and attention to the context – state and anthropological – offered by the history and society of the time: without which it would have been impossible to understand the dynastic and political, international and local reasons behind the events.
We wanted to give particular, if not primary, prominence to an “authentic portrait” of Ferdinand IV, King of Naples and Sicily or later Ferdinand I of the Two Sicilies and Grand Master of the Constantinian Order. A portrait that from first-hand sources (diaries, correspondence, newspapers, documents) appears essential not only to any history of the “golden Constantinian Order”, but also to an impartial history of the Kingdom of the greatest Italian Bourbon. As Eugenio Di Rienzo wrote, “Ferdinand IV [was] a monarch whose personality was systematically distorted and debased in the judgements of his contemporaries and subsequent historiography up to the present day.” The King was different from the person in these accounts, the man was different. It was necessary to review thoroughly the old “stereotype according to which the fate of the Neapolitan Kingdom was entrusted to the hands of the strong-willed queen consort, born Archduchess Maria Carolina of Habsburg-Lorraine and the pro-English Secretary of State, John Francis Edward Acton. Under the mask […] of the lazy King that has been handed down to us, the Sovereign hid a decisive iron will, careful to defend his prerogatives in order to hold exclusively the helm of the politics of his State.” Passionate about both the sea and the land (hunting was his only known pastime), a hard worker (between four and five in the morning he was already at his desk), religious in the real sense and not for appearances, an indefatigable reader, and an amateur musician of excellent taste, he never bowed to anyone other than the preponderant force of enemy and friendly arms.
He loved his people in a way that is perhaps unique in the history of the Kingdom of Naples. He gave a firm attention to his orders of chivalry and knew well the values of meritocracy and prestige, of dynastic continuity and honorific decentralization. Yes, even in the sometimes pressing reckonings of politics and war, the King’s pronouncements and the book’s text always reserve a recurring space for attention to the Constantinian Order.
The reconstruction of the historical events described here is based on objective sources and has effortlessly demythologized the vaunted purity of the revolutionaries, whether others or our own, and the purported “civilisation” brought by the French to the Kingdom of Naples, and finally the so-called “popular hatred towards the Bourbons,” which never existed. That such hatred towards the Bourbons never existed is evident in the letters, public statements and thoughts of Napoleon and his men. To preserve the acuity of the original texts, the book has left the correspondence and proclamations of the Bonapartes in French. The Restoration and the explicit desire of the Congress of Vienna to bring Ferdinand IV back to the throne of Naples will show – upon his return to Parthenope – how much the king was in turn loved by those people whose feelings towards the Crown changed long after his death.
The intimate and inevitable link between this current study and our previous historical novel Il vitello rampante (Arachne, Rome, 2021) cannot be hidden: time, some events, numerous deductions, some emblematic documents are necessarily the same. However, that novel had a particularly private and family dimension, in contrast to the new book which breathes the great space of the public history of a kingdom and an order of chivalry.
We do not believe we have reconstructed the entirety of a tapestry which in large areas has suffered the irreparable wear and tear of time and bad weather. A better understanding of some aspects of the history of the Sacred Military Constantinian Order of Saint George and its Grand Master, however, is perhaps now possible.
Rome, Christmas 2023
Rev. Maurizio Modugno
Index
Preface by Prince Pedro of Bourbon-Two Sicilies
Introduction
Acknowledgements
Chapter I. The most magnificent court in Europe
Chapter II. Court calendar and newsletter
Chapter III. The emperor’s knights
Chapter IV. Magnus Magister
Chapter V. Naples, who stays and who leaves
Chapter VI. The Palace of Destiny
Chapter VII. The King has left, long live the King! (almost)
Chapter VIII. Ancient and new honours
Chapter IX. January 1812
Chapter X. The pain of Trinacria and the happiness of Partenope
Chapter XI. Fires and outbreaks, present and future
Chapter XII. Other Orders of the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies
(Appendix)
Bibliography
Index of names
From the back cover
“At the end of August 1815 the newspapers of Naples announced that on 7 September, one year after her death, the solemn funeral of Queen Maria Carolina will be celebrated in the Basilica of San Paolo Maggiore. ‘The church is nobly and sumptuously covered in brown, dotted with gold crosses and stars with a truly royal design. The burial crypt could not be imagined to be more magnificent or better executed, the concert was great, the funeral oration was recited by Monsignor Pinto, Archbishop of Salerno, the music was by Paisiello; five absolutions are given by five Bishops, the last by our Archbishop. It was noticed that some brilliant ladies showed up dressed in white in grand gala and feathers, and the gentlemen who were to receive them were condemned for having admitted them, when they should have sent them away, telling them that they were going to a funeral and not to a ball.’ Furthermore, King Ferdinand who, certainly with some emotion, attended the ceremony, was no longer “a widower” in the current state of affairs. Fifty days after the death of Maria Carolina, that is, on 27 November 1814, His Majesty had married in the dazzling Palatine Chapel of Palermo – with special archiepiscopal dispensation and as a morganatic union – Donna Lucia Migliaccio, Duchess of Floridia, who in turn was the widow of Prince Benedetto Grifeo di Partanna. Born in 1770, she was considered one of the most attractive women in Sicily and perhaps in the entire Kingdom: she had had nine children, of whom it had long been rumored that the last child, Duchess Marianna, was the result of the relationship with Ferdinand, which had been ongoing since 1808. It was not only the sensual beauty of the ‘Floridiana’ that had enchanted the King: she had a docile and conciliatory character, but was always extraordinarily aware of what her role as non-queen consort allowed her. Over time she was also be able to win the respect and perhaps the affection of Ferdinand’s children, of whom Francis was initially particularly hostile to her. Marie-Henriette Prévost de la Boutellière, Baroness du Montet, after being introduced to her in Vienna on the occasion of a meeting of the Holy Alliance in 1822, would write about her in her famous Memoirs: ‘The Duchess of Floridia is somewhat secluded. She is a petite woman who is still beautiful and very well preserved, well-built and dark-haired. She shows infinite tact in her public interactions with the King and the imperial family, never falling below the dignity of the King’s wife without the title of Queen.’ And it seems that often, after his return to Naples, Ferdinand kept repeating: ‘I have a wife who lets me do what I want and a Minister [Luigi de’ Medici) who leaves me little to do!’ “
ABOVE: The cover of the book
BELOW: Portrait of King Ferdinand IV of Naples and III of Sicily (later King Ferdinand I of the Two Sicilies). Entitled Ferdinand IV of Bourbon and attributed to Francesco Liani, the portrait, oil on cloth, was painted in the second half of the 18th century and hangs in the Provincial Museum of Campania in the Palazzo Antignano in Capua, Italy

